The Butcher
Legendary Pubber
- Joined
- Apr 29, 2017
- Messages
- 4,652
- Reaction score
- 12,147
Just finished Book 6 (Babylon's Ashes) of The Expanse. I like how the authors really raised the stakes in the last two books, which feel more like a series and less like "The Adventures of Holden & Friends." Looking forward to Book 7.
Now imagine me saying in a Jerry Seinfeld voice if you must, but what's the deal with the novel titles?
It's easy to see how they were going for something evocative, but let's stop and think about each for a second:
Leviathan Wakes — Sure, OK, the protomolecule takes over Venus and the result is a big monstrosity. Works for me.
Caliban's War — Because the Martian general who weaponized the protomolecule is a dick, I guess? So he's like Caliban from The Tempest? Um, okay.
Abbadon's Gate — Abbadon being Hebrew for "destruction" and also a name for a demon from Revelations (a.k.a. Apollyon). Nothing in the book suggests that the gates themselves will lead to destruction. The only way this works is if you read Book 5 and call it foreshadowing; to which I call bullshit.
Cibola Burn — Cibola being one of the cities of Eldorado, and Ilus/New Terra being the Eldorado in question? Okay. Where's the "burn" though? No one is racing there.
Nemesis Games — works because Marco Inaros spends this book and the next going all Khan Noonien Singh on Holden's can't-we-all-just-get-along act, less because he's pissing on the Free Navy's cheetos (that's more of a Book 6 thing) more because he's porking his baby mama.
And in keeping with the Star Trek analogies, can we agree that Filip is mirror-Universe Wesley Crusher?
Babylon's Ashes — sort of works as the old empires have been shot to shit, "alas, Babylon" and all. But like the previous title, generic as fuck.
Persepolis Rising — lemme guess, disgruntled MCRN Admiral Winston Duarte (the guy supplying Marco with MCRN stuff) props up Laconia as the Persia to the Solar System's disgruntled, chaotic Peloponnesian League. I now fully expect a space Thermopylae by the gates where a ton of people will die but turn back his budding evil space empire.
It's easy to see how they were going for something evocative, but let's stop and think about each for a second:
Leviathan Wakes — Sure, OK, the protomolecule takes over Venus and the result is a big monstrosity. Works for me.
Caliban's War — Because the Martian general who weaponized the protomolecule is a dick, I guess? So he's like Caliban from The Tempest? Um, okay.
Abbadon's Gate — Abbadon being Hebrew for "destruction" and also a name for a demon from Revelations (a.k.a. Apollyon). Nothing in the book suggests that the gates themselves will lead to destruction. The only way this works is if you read Book 5 and call it foreshadowing; to which I call bullshit.
Cibola Burn — Cibola being one of the cities of Eldorado, and Ilus/New Terra being the Eldorado in question? Okay. Where's the "burn" though? No one is racing there.
Nemesis Games — works because Marco Inaros spends this book and the next going all Khan Noonien Singh on Holden's can't-we-all-just-get-along act, less because he's pissing on the Free Navy's cheetos (that's more of a Book 6 thing) more because he's porking his baby mama.
And in keeping with the Star Trek analogies, can we agree that Filip is mirror-Universe Wesley Crusher?
Babylon's Ashes — sort of works as the old empires have been shot to shit, "alas, Babylon" and all. But like the previous title, generic as fuck.
Persepolis Rising — lemme guess, disgruntled MCRN Admiral Winston Duarte (the guy supplying Marco with MCRN stuff) props up Laconia as the Persia to the Solar System's disgruntled, chaotic Peloponnesian League. I now fully expect a space Thermopylae by the gates where a ton of people will die but turn back his budding evil space empire.