What do you do if the reaction roll is
If you already got a reaction roll, then you're not just making to hit rolls.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
What do you do if the reaction roll is
If you already got a reaction roll, then you're not just making to hit rolls.
if that's the case, then I have absolutely no idea what you mean when you say that all you can do in D&D is make to hit rolls.
I hope that "you" does not mean me, since I haven't said that and am quite sure it's not true.
Sorry, got you and Moonbum mixed up.
I'd love to read some examples from you.if all you do in D&D is make to hit rolls, you suck at D&D. Learn to play n00b, as the kids say.
So how did you meet Dave?
OK, Gronan, can you give us a lesson ? I think that would be rather useful (and in line with the purpose of the thread, actually), so please treat is a question!
I mean, for a start, tell us what you do in these two variants of the same situation - that's not to-hit rolls... it might help us next time, who knows?
"You encounter a raiding party of orcs, but they don't look like your typical orc, what with all of them having chain mail of actual good quality. You have three fighting men of 2nd level and a 1st level Cleric, who is leading two religiously-motivated henchmen".
The henchmen, fighters and cleric are armed as you wish, but have no more than lamelar armour (but aren't injured yet ). The orcs have 2 swords, 2 axes, and 2 HD for the two swordsgoblinoids and 3 HD for the two "crazy axe murderers" (which is what they are, they go berserk if a fight starts - but also defer to the leadership of the other two when it comes to the question when a fight would start).
The room is 20X20 feet. There's a chest in the middle of it that the orcs have been sitting around, draperies on the walls, and . Neither side has surprise, nor did anyone spot the other side in advance (the sword-bearing orcs were playing cards around the chest, in an uncharacteristically silent manner, but they're orcs...the weapons are near their hands).
What do you do if the roll is reaction roll indicates "negative, don't attack...yet"?
What do you do if the reaction roll is "they attack"?
If it matters, those are orc chieftains and their guards, who had gathered to discuss nuptial arrangements between the tribes. Not able to decide which side should have the upper hand, they agreed to settle it as their shamans (not present) instructed them: with a game of cards.
I know, those ain't your typical orcs (they might well be any humans/humanoids, though I was thinking of the "orcs" from the Red Tide setting), but then it's not about playing a typical "just charge them and hope we win" scenario, right ?
I'd love to read some examples from you.
This is a BIG problem with later editions; flanking is vastly underpowered. Flanking wins battles.
This is a BIG problem with later editions; flanking is vastly underpowered. Flanking wins battles.
Scenario 1: One of the sewordsmen looks at you, and makes a gesture towards the others, which you interpret as "hold it for now".Well, I don't know what their reaction roll is. All I know is what do they do?
That was for you as a Referee, because you are a Referee . You wouldn't be running all the PCs, either...but in this case, that's what I'm asking you to do, for the sake of the example, so you'd have to act partially as Referee, here.How do I know how many HD the orcs have? There is no way I can have that information.
Let's keep it simple: all of you are interested in loot.Why are we down in the dungeon? For loot or some other reason?
Are you telling me that only magic makes things different from "exchanging to-hit rolls" or what ?And why the hell don't we have at least one magic user with us? A group of three 2nd level fighters should be able to scrape up enough for to hire a 1st level magic user with a SLEEP spell, at least.
I think this is due to the fact that, by then, most fights were supposed to look like "superhero spectacle fights" from movies. When you have 4 supers vs 6 villains with everyone doing his own thing, concepts like "formation" cease to matter.
Wait, D&D is played without flanking rules now?5e has pretty extensive optional flanking rules in the DMG if one wants them. To me if you're going to bring flanking into combat you'd be better off with a more tactical game like TFT, although I think TFT could also easily be played without those rules, same as D&D is most often played without them.
Scenario 1: One of the sewordsmen looks at you, and makes a gesture towards the others, which you interpret as "hold it for now".
"Who in the Circle of Pain are you, interrupting our game? Turn back from whence you came and leave now, and we won't give chase. Otherwise, your lives would be forfeit!"
Scenario 2: "Aaaargh! Weak, insolent elfkin*!"
Charge-slash-chop-stab from the Berserkers and one of the warriors. The other warrior throws a throwing axe (or throwing stick, or javelin) over the heads of the melee, aiming not at your fighters, but at the torchbearer (because orcs see in the dark better than you, and they know it).
*An orkish invective aimed at humans/hobbits/half-elves, always pronounced in Common to make sure it's understood. It means roughly "those weaklings who try to be like the elves, but suck at it".
That was for you as a Referee, because you are a Referee . You wouldn't be running all the PCs, either...but in this case, that's what I'm asking you to do, for the sake of the example, so you'd have to act partially as Referee, here.
Instead of HDs, you should read "they have the eyes, and controlled movements, of people who have killed many a times and might be tempted to do it again...and for some of them, it probably wouldn't require much temptation".
Let's keep it simple: all of you are interested in loot.
On top of this, the cleric has heard about a fountain that bestows unholy magical power, deep down in the dungeon, and wants to have it shut off, destroyed or purified. One of the fighting men had also heard about it, but believes the part about "paying with your soul for the power" is made up and might be tempted to take a bath.
Are you telling me that only magic makes things different from "exchanging to-hit rolls" or what ?
As to the reasons:
Because the GM believed that only PCs are crazy enough to join an expedition to the dungeon, and thus wouldn't join a delve (the NPCs believe you wouldn't make it this time, because your luck is bound to run out)? That was actual advice in some DMGs, I believe.
Because the GM has a setting where wizards are incredibly scarce, unlike fighters and clerics, thus making the price of their services beyond the current grasp of the group?
Have your pick. Me, I've played with both of those guys!
Gronan, were you around for any of Gary's other classic modules, like Temple of Elemental Evil, Against the Giants, Against the Drow or Queen of the Demonweb Pits?
That's part of what I like about The Fantasy Trip: you're a wizard, or not a wizard, and then you have various talents.
T&T does this as well. You are a Warrior (use any weapon, double protection from armor and shields), Wizard (only use 2d weapon but you have MAGIC obvs), or a Rogue (any weapon, no armor bonus, can use magic but only at full casting cost and no Guild will teach you new spells because you are a filthy casual). But, skills weren't added until 7th (I think) Edition.
Edit: older[/] versions of T&T did this, they added (unnecessary IMO) classes later on...
...OK, let's drop this tangent. If it's not fun for either of us, there's no point.I am now totally confused. I have no idea what you're even asking me.
Similar to the flanking issue, are there any other rules that you remember that were regularly used but weren't listed in the rules for OD&D?
I think we intuitively figured it out from CHAINMAIL; a Hero went from 4 hits to 4 HD, so weapons went from doing a hit to a die. I think.
So, if I wanted to emulate this with another system, the HD would be analogous to #/hits the target can take, right? Assuming variable weapon damage, how much damage, on average, constitutes a “hit?” I’m thinking 4.5, based on the way current 5E monsters go. Unless I have that wrong. Going from memory here, because smoking cigars and drinking bourbon limits my personal bandwidth.:-)
What brand?
OD&D was back in the d6 days so a die was 3.5 points.
Hit dice also started out as d6, with Magic Users and Clerics getting 1d6 at level 1 and Fighters getting 1d6+1. Variable hit dice appeared in Greyhawk along with variable damage.Alright, so damage started out as a flat d6. This makes sense. If hit die varied by class and a d4 wizard wasn't an immediate death sentence, but it's much more dangerous.
At what point did weapons begin taking on different damage values, and how did you and others react to this?
And, as was already mentioned earlier in this thread, Gronan of Simmerya is actually the one who originally suggested the adding variable damage by weapon type (which is presumably why he gets a "Thanks to" credit in that book) - a suggestion he later came to regret.Hit dice also started out as d6, with Magic Users and Clerics getting 1d6 at level 1 and Fighters getting 1d6+1. Variable hit dice appeared in Greyhawk along with variable damage.
I'd expect you explored locations that appeared in modules but that they weren't canned or packaged as modules.Well, as I've said before, Gary never announced a name of an adventure; he didn't say "tonight you are going to the Steading of the Hill Giant Chief." I don't remember being in any of those you mentioned.
Well, there's always the basics; second rank with long spears,
Again because the rules presume knowledge of medieval combat and thus knowing that ordinarily you can't move the front rank unless it one of several specific circumstance like charging on horseback. Even then those circumstance may not work due to specifics defenses.heavy fighters form a line to protect the casters while the light fighters/thieves move into a flank position.
Flanking works in a similar way to having people fighting in the 2nd rank with long spears. It allows attacking force to have more people fighting in melee than they otherwise could. In addition for the portion of the line that is flanking the enemy has far less attack than they do when the two front line are engaged. It quite possible to have a series of 5 on 1 fights that just roll up and crush the enemy line. Also with flanking you don't need a specific class of weapon to make it work for you.You should ALWAYS attempt to flank the enemy force.
What would help folks is learning about your experience in handling this without miniatures.This is a BIG problem with later editions; flanking is vastly underpowered. Flanking wins battles.
It's not rules, it's small unit tactics. The problem is, the hobby has drifted by several decades from it's wargaming roots. So things that seem obvious to some aren't to others. Tactics being a big part of this.None of this stuff is actually part of original edition D&D rules books, so effectively what we are talking about here is the introduction of your own house rules to fill in important details. Groanin' hasn't said what those rules are (or were) at his table — we just know he thinks it is obvious we should be be using them. So it is difficult to follow exactly what he means.