- Joined
- Apr 24, 2017
- Messages
- 33,126
- Reaction score
- 96,700
For the month of October this year I've decide to watch one classic horror film a night. I'll probably play pretty fast and loose with the definition of "classic", but I' looking for films that are "Archetypal" and acclaimed, and ones that I haven't seen in a while or never seen.
I started with Universal's 1935 Bride of Frankenstein, a film I've not watched since my early adolescence. This is often hailed as one of the, if not the best, of the Universal Classic Monster movies. And....I don't know why, to be honest. I disliked it when I was a teen, but after year of reading the critical acclaim, and seeing it on numerous "best of" lists, I've always meant to give it another go, to see if there was something I missed; something my more mature zoetropic palette could detect. But...it's really just not a good film.
We start with a vignette about Shelly, authoress of Frankenstein, and her husband Blake hanging out with Byron, though not as part of that famous weekend in which Frankenstein was first conceived, but after it has been submitted for publication. Byron is played as a fop, Blake appears only barely cognizant, so really the standout of the scene is Shelly herself played by Elsa Lanchester, who also played the bride. I almost imagine this scene was added after the fact just to showcase her talent a bit more, because she is far and away the standout performance of the film.
As a framing device though - no, that's the wrong word, because while I expected the film to return to this scene at it's climax, no such thing happens - it's perfunctory at best, basically Byron praising the original Frankenstein tale and wondering what happens next, and so Shelly proceeds to tell him. Enter the film proper.
What we are then subjected to is basically a retread of the original story mixed with a bizarre story of Frankentein's former teacher showing up and wanting him to continue his original experiments. The teacher, the closest thing to a villain in the film, tries to entice Frankenstein with this batshit insane scene where he shows off these miniature people he created. It's amusing as just whimsical nonsense, but it's completely off in tone and is entirely random.
Unfortunately, it takes most of the rest of the film until the "plot" actually gets underway, with the screen time largely taken up by Frankenstein's original monster getting chased by villagers due to one misunderstanding after another. The pacing is horrible, and nothing seems to be driving the main plot forward, insteadthe film just stumbles along with me just waiting for the climax. Finally, the monster meets up with the teacher, and they hatch a plan (somehow - the intelligence of the monster seems to alter from one scene to the next, from "Grrrr, fire bad!" to "I'm going to blackmail my creator into making me a mate by kidnapping his fiance").So yea, finally in the late 15 minutes of the film things start to actually happen. The monster steals Frank's fiance, forcing him to work with his old teacher to create the titular bride, using animate corpses again procured by Igor (who just happens to "show up" towards the end of the film when he's needed) but a brain grown by the teacher, in an unspecified manner similar to his magic homunculi.
And the Bride is pretty cool. For the whole 3 minutes of screen time she gets, before the monster realizes she's scared of him (which I can't help but think is less to do with his appearance, like the villagers, but instead the fact that just after coming to life he's on her like jam on toast like a creepy stalker), and then get mad and....this was the part that made me mentally groan the loudest...decides to pull the big lever (never before shown or mentioned) that blows up the lab. Why does this lever exist? Like, who builds a giant tower, installs a bunch of scientific and medical equipment, and then finishes everything off by installing a lever that I can only guess is for some reason wired to several tons of dynamite hidden in the tower walls?
For some reason the monster lets Frank and his fiance go first, because, I guess there needed to be a "happy" ending? I dunno, there was nothing remotely likeable about either character. And then pulls lever, and an obvious miniature goes boom and falls apart in slow motion. The end.
My impression hasn't changed since my first viewing as a young teen - if anything, it's worse. The film is clumsily written and misses every obvious chance for anything remotely interesting.
But the odd thing that occurred to me while I was watching, constantly thinking of things I would have done differently, is the question as to why the film was never remade? There is a potentially interesting story in there, even if it totally drops the ball when presenting it.
Imagine this - the film starts with the monster escaping the villagers the first time, where he immediately encounters the teacher character. The teacher knows who and what the monster is, and takes it under his wing, beginning to educate it while he studies it. But he cannot uncover the secrets of the monster, and the monster, once able to articulate, is miserable, complaining about the loneliness of it's unique existence. So it's here, in the first act, that the teacher comes up with the plan to force Frankenstein to recreate his experiment, by creating a bride for the creature. The monster kidnaps Frankenstein's fiance, and this plays out much like in the original (just kicking off the middle of the film rather than a truncated last act).
There is this one scene in the film. Frankenstein, frustrated, demands to know that his fiance is still alive, and the teacher says he cannot see her, but he can talk to her over the phone. In the original, it's just as it sounds, he picks up the phone an talks to his fiance, who is kept in some rather risque-placed bondage by the monster somewhere nearby. I was soooo disappointed by this, because I thought the film was going in a way creepier, more disturbing direction. I don't even know why, in the context of the film, he had to communicate by phone, with the monster there, she could have just been tied to hair in the corner of the lab. But imagine this, he calls the phone, and speaks to her, an she is confused and disorientated, and just says "it's dark here, I don't know where I am, I can't see anything!" and Frankenstein just thinks they have her in some sort of cellar or something, but it's suddenly revealed that the teacher extracted the brain of the fiance, and that is in a vat, with a sort of weird-science phonograph-like contraption attached allowing it to talk - and that is the brain that the teacher gives to Frankenstein to put inside the bride!
Then, once the bride is animated, instead of just this two minute sequence where she confusedly screams while the monster paws at her, the Bride is immediately and obviously attracted to Frankenstein and wants nothing to do with the monster's attempts at affection, but clings to Frankenstein and tries to communicate with him. It's then the teacher finally reveals what brain Frankenstein put inside the Bride, driving him mad, and the Bride, ambiguously perhaps regaining some cognizance of her original self, kills the teacher. The monster, furious at the Bride's rejection and jealous of her obvious preference for their creator, attacks Frankenstein and their desperate battle leads to the lab an then the bride catching on fire. Both the monster and Frankenstein rush to try and save her, but are too late, as the fire reaches the chemicals, causing an explosion that buries her. As the inferno rages and the lab crashes down around them, Frankenstein tries to get to the exit, when a beam comes falling down toward him and he closes his eyes, holding up his arms, expecting to die....only to open them to find the monster has saved him, holding up the scaffolding with his back.
Cue a much shorter and more stilted Roy Batty-esque speech from the Monster as he gives Frankenstein the chance to escape, looking back one last time to look at his pitiful creation before it's strength gives out and the flames consume it.
The End

I started with Universal's 1935 Bride of Frankenstein, a film I've not watched since my early adolescence. This is often hailed as one of the, if not the best, of the Universal Classic Monster movies. And....I don't know why, to be honest. I disliked it when I was a teen, but after year of reading the critical acclaim, and seeing it on numerous "best of" lists, I've always meant to give it another go, to see if there was something I missed; something my more mature zoetropic palette could detect. But...it's really just not a good film.
We start with a vignette about Shelly, authoress of Frankenstein, and her husband Blake hanging out with Byron, though not as part of that famous weekend in which Frankenstein was first conceived, but after it has been submitted for publication. Byron is played as a fop, Blake appears only barely cognizant, so really the standout of the scene is Shelly herself played by Elsa Lanchester, who also played the bride. I almost imagine this scene was added after the fact just to showcase her talent a bit more, because she is far and away the standout performance of the film.
As a framing device though - no, that's the wrong word, because while I expected the film to return to this scene at it's climax, no such thing happens - it's perfunctory at best, basically Byron praising the original Frankenstein tale and wondering what happens next, and so Shelly proceeds to tell him. Enter the film proper.
What we are then subjected to is basically a retread of the original story mixed with a bizarre story of Frankentein's former teacher showing up and wanting him to continue his original experiments. The teacher, the closest thing to a villain in the film, tries to entice Frankenstein with this batshit insane scene where he shows off these miniature people he created. It's amusing as just whimsical nonsense, but it's completely off in tone and is entirely random.
Unfortunately, it takes most of the rest of the film until the "plot" actually gets underway, with the screen time largely taken up by Frankenstein's original monster getting chased by villagers due to one misunderstanding after another. The pacing is horrible, and nothing seems to be driving the main plot forward, insteadthe film just stumbles along with me just waiting for the climax. Finally, the monster meets up with the teacher, and they hatch a plan (somehow - the intelligence of the monster seems to alter from one scene to the next, from "Grrrr, fire bad!" to "I'm going to blackmail my creator into making me a mate by kidnapping his fiance").So yea, finally in the late 15 minutes of the film things start to actually happen. The monster steals Frank's fiance, forcing him to work with his old teacher to create the titular bride, using animate corpses again procured by Igor (who just happens to "show up" towards the end of the film when he's needed) but a brain grown by the teacher, in an unspecified manner similar to his magic homunculi.
And the Bride is pretty cool. For the whole 3 minutes of screen time she gets, before the monster realizes she's scared of him (which I can't help but think is less to do with his appearance, like the villagers, but instead the fact that just after coming to life he's on her like jam on toast like a creepy stalker), and then get mad and....this was the part that made me mentally groan the loudest...decides to pull the big lever (never before shown or mentioned) that blows up the lab. Why does this lever exist? Like, who builds a giant tower, installs a bunch of scientific and medical equipment, and then finishes everything off by installing a lever that I can only guess is for some reason wired to several tons of dynamite hidden in the tower walls?
For some reason the monster lets Frank and his fiance go first, because, I guess there needed to be a "happy" ending? I dunno, there was nothing remotely likeable about either character. And then pulls lever, and an obvious miniature goes boom and falls apart in slow motion. The end.
My impression hasn't changed since my first viewing as a young teen - if anything, it's worse. The film is clumsily written and misses every obvious chance for anything remotely interesting.
But the odd thing that occurred to me while I was watching, constantly thinking of things I would have done differently, is the question as to why the film was never remade? There is a potentially interesting story in there, even if it totally drops the ball when presenting it.
Imagine this - the film starts with the monster escaping the villagers the first time, where he immediately encounters the teacher character. The teacher knows who and what the monster is, and takes it under his wing, beginning to educate it while he studies it. But he cannot uncover the secrets of the monster, and the monster, once able to articulate, is miserable, complaining about the loneliness of it's unique existence. So it's here, in the first act, that the teacher comes up with the plan to force Frankenstein to recreate his experiment, by creating a bride for the creature. The monster kidnaps Frankenstein's fiance, and this plays out much like in the original (just kicking off the middle of the film rather than a truncated last act).
There is this one scene in the film. Frankenstein, frustrated, demands to know that his fiance is still alive, and the teacher says he cannot see her, but he can talk to her over the phone. In the original, it's just as it sounds, he picks up the phone an talks to his fiance, who is kept in some rather risque-placed bondage by the monster somewhere nearby. I was soooo disappointed by this, because I thought the film was going in a way creepier, more disturbing direction. I don't even know why, in the context of the film, he had to communicate by phone, with the monster there, she could have just been tied to hair in the corner of the lab. But imagine this, he calls the phone, and speaks to her, an she is confused and disorientated, and just says "it's dark here, I don't know where I am, I can't see anything!" and Frankenstein just thinks they have her in some sort of cellar or something, but it's suddenly revealed that the teacher extracted the brain of the fiance, and that is in a vat, with a sort of weird-science phonograph-like contraption attached allowing it to talk - and that is the brain that the teacher gives to Frankenstein to put inside the bride!
Then, once the bride is animated, instead of just this two minute sequence where she confusedly screams while the monster paws at her, the Bride is immediately and obviously attracted to Frankenstein and wants nothing to do with the monster's attempts at affection, but clings to Frankenstein and tries to communicate with him. It's then the teacher finally reveals what brain Frankenstein put inside the Bride, driving him mad, and the Bride, ambiguously perhaps regaining some cognizance of her original self, kills the teacher. The monster, furious at the Bride's rejection and jealous of her obvious preference for their creator, attacks Frankenstein and their desperate battle leads to the lab an then the bride catching on fire. Both the monster and Frankenstein rush to try and save her, but are too late, as the fire reaches the chemicals, causing an explosion that buries her. As the inferno rages and the lab crashes down around them, Frankenstein tries to get to the exit, when a beam comes falling down toward him and he closes his eyes, holding up his arms, expecting to die....only to open them to find the monster has saved him, holding up the scaffolding with his back.
Cue a much shorter and more stilted Roy Batty-esque speech from the Monster as he gives Frankenstein the chance to escape, looking back one last time to look at his pitiful creation before it's strength gives out and the flames consume it.
The End

