Imperator
Legendary Pubber
- Joined
- May 8, 2017
- Messages
- 166
- Reaction score
- 363
That is my impression, as well. I see how it oculd have been written better, and it's unlikely I would use it in my games, but it was nothing to call home about.Have you seen the offending section? Honestly, it was a tempest in a teacup. I'm not saying it wasn't clunky and even a bit bad taste. But it only gained traction because some people were looking for reasons to hate V5 already. I've said elsewhere that if it had appeared in an Arc Dream game nobody would have batted an eyelid.
No, please, you have been absolutely polite IMO, no problem with you giving a different opinion. You are welcome.I'm always glad to hear when some tries out a new edition or a new playstyle for the first time and hear what they have today about it. I apologize if I hijacked your thread with my grumblings.
This is very interesting. I think you are on to something.There is some types of campaign I think V20 does do better. Partly because V5 has a much tighter design focus. Which I've come to prefer these days, but a lot of people like toolkits.
What I think V20 is better suited for, at least currently:
Elder campaigns.
Sabbat campaigns.
Gonzo anything goes games.
V5 is better at:
Anarch campaigns.
Locally focused campaigns.
Horror in general.
What neither are good at:
Action adventure.
T Trippy , I didn't know that Anarch and Camarilla were going to be discontinued. Even if they're not essential (and they're not), at least you should be able to find the mechanics information (new clans & disciplines, loresheets and the like) somewhere. Any word on that?